Menu
Home About Us Our Strategy Megatrends Contact Us

Any Reason to Invest in Anything but US Equities?

02 January 2025

"For much of the past two decades, you could have pointed out that European stocks were cheaper, relative to earnings, than American stocks. You could have reasonably argued that this portended better investment returns and less risk of crashes. And for all that time you would have been utterly, gloriously wrong"

The Economist

By Niels Clemen Jensen
Article PDF Download

Welcome to 2025

As always, the January Absolute Return Letter is about issues that are at the forefront of our minds – issues (risks) that keep us awake at night because they could have a profound impact on equity returns, should they come to fruition.

And, as always, I shall be the first to admit that the true sledgehammer – the bombshell which could wipe out vast amounts of wealth – is likely to come out of the blue. Did anyone really plan for the pandemic? Maybe when the reality started to sink in, and large amounts of wealth had already been lost – but beforehand? Get my point? The true mega-risks are almost always those we don’t even think about.

With that in mind, today, I will list a few risks that dominate the mindsets of the staff at Absolute Return Partners as we have just entered a New Year. A few weeks ago, I sent an email to my colleagues, asking them to list the issues they worry most about, and today’s Absolute Return Letter is a small collection of the worries that dominated those lists. With those comments, let’s begin.

What to worry most about as we enter 2025

I. The absurd valuation of US megacap stocks

In 1986, I landed a job in London, selling US equities to Scandinavian institutional investors, and, for the next four years, I had to listen to clients who kept arguing why Japanese equities were so much better than US equities, and why they were not at all overvalued which they appeared to be (to me).

As you may remember, the Nikkei 225 Index peaked in August 1990 before the bubble burst, a downturn which led to losses of about 80% over the next 19 years. In the years after the GFC, the Nikkei 225 began to recover; however, the old peak of August 1990 was only surpassed in May 2023, almost 33 years later. In other words, it took almost half a lifetime to fully recover from the large losses caused by the burst of the Japanese wealth bubble.

Now, replace Japan anno 1990 with the US anno 2025. I am already looking forward to the dozens of emails I will receive, mostly from US investors who will tell me that you cannot compare Japan 35 years ago with the US today. They will argue that US equities are on much firmer ground today than Japanese equities ever were, and I will (quietly) conclude that this aura of supremacy is precisely why the current feast will end in tears.

Take a look at Exhibit 1. As you can see, since we came out of the GFC in early 2009, US equities have performed dramatically better than European equities, and one is entitled to wonder why one should invest in anything but US equities.

--image--

The extraordinary returns on (certain) US stocks have led to a huge appetite for equities amongst US retail investors, and nowhere is that more visible than when you look at flows into US equity ETFs which, for the first time ever, surpassed $1 trillion last year (Exhibit 2). Needless to say, record inflows aren’t necessarily all new money but, when you combine Exhibits 1 and 2, I would argue that a fair amount of it is.

--image2--

Sophisticated investors may have begun to realise that Trump’s policy programme (more on that later) will, if implemented as announced, come at a huge price; however, around the speculative fringes, the risk-talking is getting bigger by the day. Single stock ETFs, which are almost exclusively bought by retail investors, are more popular than ever. According to Bloomberg, leveraged, single-stock ETFs have been particularly popular in 2024. I suggest you take a quick look at Exhibit 3 below, which depicts the flows into an ETF which invests exclusively in Nvidia common stock on a leveraged basis. As you can see AuM have risen from a few hundred million dollars to well over $5 billion over the last 12 months.

--image3--

II. The Yen carry trade

Closely linked to our worry that the US equity bubble may be coming to the end of its runway, are our concerns related to the Yen carry trade. For those of you who don’t know what the Yen carry trade is, here is how it works. Essentially, you borrow in Japanese yen (JPY), where interest rates are low, and invest the proceeds in currencies that offer higher returns such as US dollars (USD). If you can borrow JPY at 0-1%, invest in USD government bonds yielding 4-5%, and at least partially hedge the currency risk as many sophisticated investors have done in recent years, it appears to be not only a very rewarding trade but also a fairly safe one. And I should stress that the yen carry trade is not only used when investing in bonds. It also explains much of the equity rally in 2024.

Now, let’s look at the implications. If JPY weakens, global liquidity increases, the reason being that investors tend to borrow more, the cheaper the currency is, leading to more capital flowing into financial markets all over the world. The side effect of this dynamic is asset price inflation, as more capital chases the same pool of investments, hence why the end-result may be a bubble.

On the other hand, if JPY strengthens, global liquidity decreases. The carry trade is now less attractive, and investors typically begin to liquidate their higher-yielding investments to pay back their JPY loans, which leads to a withdrawal of capital from financial markets, effectively reducing global liquidity. The impact? Declining risk asset prices.

The bottom line is that JPY movements act like a global liquidity tap, and JPY fluctuations will typically affect all risk assets – not just bonds. In July 2024, BoJ raised Japanese interest rates for the first time in 17 years (from 0.00% to 0.25%), and JPY began to rally, which affected financial markets worldwide. Remember the mayhem in early August of last year? Our concern now is that BoJ has a long way to go with respect to its hiking plans, and that Japanese interest rates will be raised a number of times in 2025 to the detriment of risk assets worldwide.

III. The impact of Trump’s policy programme

US Election Day turned out to be a sweep for the Republican Party, i.e., at least for the next two years, Trump will benefit from a control of Congress. As a consequence, he will enjoy sufficient powers to act on most of the promises he made when campaigning recently. That said, one thing is what he says he’ll do. Another thing is what he actually ends up doing. You never quite know with Trump.

The most likely near-term changes are those that can be executed under the Executive Order mandate and, in that category, tariffs and deportation of illegal immigrants stand out. Trump is clearly intent on using tariffs as a weapon against trading counterparties, and you should expect him to act quickly. He is keen to demonstrate that he meant it seriously when he talked about raising them, and it won’t require months of preparatory work in Congress. Precisely by how much and vis-à-vis whom is difficult to say, though. When it comes to Trump, I have learned that what he does is not necessarily predicated on what he says he will do. And he obviously uses the threat of tariffs as a negotiation tactic.

Let’s assume Trump goes for the Full Monty – the High Scenario in Exhibit 4 below. As you can see, the impact on US inflation will be dramatic. Even a much softer version, where tariffs are increased less dramatically and fewer illegal immigrants deported (the Low Scenario in Exhibit 4), will have a significant impact on US inflation.

--image4--

2025 is therefore likely to end up in a power struggle between hardcore MAGA supporters and more pragmatic Republicans in Congress who realise that, if fully implemented, Trump’s policy programme will lead to misery. If the MAGA movement win that battle, the Fed will almost certainly raise interest rates, and that will be costly. Mortgage holders will suffer, and so will US equity markets. Under those conditions, 2025 could turn out to be a rather dubious experience.

Final few words

Today, I have only started to scratch the surface on this topic. My colleagues provided me with many more concerns of theirs, many of which I will cover over the next few months. To me, the first concern raised in today’s letter – are we coming to the end of the great equity bull market, which started in earnest in early 2009? – is the most important one. I learnt a very serious lesson in connection with the collapse of the Japanese bubble in the early 1990s. When bubbles burst, the implications are far more dramatic than when we ‘just’ go from bull market to bear market conditions. Therefore, a ‘so what?’ attitude could be very costly.

Having said that, I also learnt that timing the end of bubbles correctly is almost impossible; there are so many dynamics pulling in either direction. Therefore, a hedging strategy may make more sense than a vanilla exit strategy which could prove terribly expensive, if your concerns turn out to be premature.

By Niels Clemen Jensen

02 January 2025

What are your thoughts? Leave a comment

Website Disclaimer

The information on this website (the “Website”) has been prepared by Absolute Return Partners LLP ("ARP"). ARP is authorised (FRN: 221250) and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (the “FCA”). It is provided for information purposes, is intended for your use only, and does not constitute an invitation or offer to subscribe for or purchase any of the products or services mentioned. The information provided is not intended to provide a sufficient basis on which to make an investment decision. Any investment in ARP will be made pursuant to written subscription materials. The information provided in this Website will be subject to, and expressly qualified by, any information contained in the subscription material. The Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) of the United States does not pass upon the accuracy or completeness of any of the information contained herein. Information and opinions presented in this Website have been obtained or derived from sources believed by ARP to be reliable, but ARP makes no representation as to their accuracy or completeness. Any views contained within this Website are those of ARP. ARP accepts no liability for any loss arising from the use of this Website. The results referred to in this Website are not a guide to the future performance of ARP. Access to the Website is restricted to retail investors. ARP does not offer investment advice to private investors (Retail Clients as defined by the FCA). If you are a private investor seeking investment advice, contact an independent financial advisor.

ARP disclaims all responsibility if you access or download any information from this Website in breach of any law or regulation in the country of which you are a citizen or in which you are residing or domiciled. All information included in this Website is subject to change without notice.

The investments discussed on the Website may not be suitable for all investors. Investors should make their own investment decisions based upon their own financial objectives and financial resources and it should be noted that investment involves risk. Investors should be aware that the market price of the securities discussed in this report may be volatile. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance and an investor may not get back the amount originally invested. Where investment is made in currencies other than the investor’s base currency, movements in exchange rates will have an effect on the value, either favourable or unfavourable. An investor may not get back the original amount invested and in the case of an illiquid stock the investor may be unable to sell at any price. Any tax relief mentioned is those currently available and are subject to change. Their value depends on the personal circumstances of the investor.

ARP Megatrend Fund (the “Fund”)

The information on the website is intended for Professional Clients only as defined in Annex II of MiFID.

There are various risks associated with the investments in the ARP Megatrend Fund (the “Fund”).The value of investments can go down as well as up and the implementation of the approach described does not guarantee positive performance. Any reference to potential asset allocation and potential returns do not represent and should not be interpreted as projections.

The distribution of the information on this Website may be restricted by law in certain countries. The Fund is currently registered for marketing purposes in Austria, Denmark, Finland, Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden, and the UK. The Website and the information on it are not addressed to any person resident in the territory or country or jurisdiction where such distribution would be contrary to local law or regulation. Please get in touch to find out more. The Website is a marketing communication. Please refer to the Prospectus and the Supplement of the Fund before making any final investment decisions.

The investments discussed on the Website may not be suitable for all investors. Investors should make their own investment decisions based upon their own financial objectives and financial resources and it should be noted that investment involves risk. Investors should be aware that the market price of the securities discussed in this report may be volatile. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance and an investor may not get back the amount originally invested. Where investment is made in currencies other than the investor’s base currency, movements in exchange rates will have an effect on the value, either favourable or unfavourable. An investor may not get back the original amount invested and in the case of an illiquid stock the investor may be unable to sell at any price. Any tax relief mentioned is those currently available and are subject to change. Their value depends on the personal circumstances of the investor. The Fund is authorised by the Central Bank of Ireland. The AIFM of the Fund is Waystone Management Company (IE) Limited (the “AIFM”).

Our website does not give investment advice

The information contained on the Website you are about to access is for information purposes only and does not constitute and should not be construed as advice on which reliance should be placed, nor is it an offer by ARP to enter into any contract or investment agreement or a solicitation to buy or sell any investment in any jurisdiction or in any circumstances. Any information provided in relation to a specific fund is not intended to provide a sufficient basis on which to make any investment decision as any such decision requires careful study of the offering memorandum of the relevant fund. We offer a paid research subscription service ARP+ offering investment advice to Professional Clients as defined by the FCA.

Our website stores information on your device

Our website uses technologies, such as cookies, to distinguish you from other users of our website, which helps us to provide you with a good experience when you browse our website and also allows us to improve our site. We do not use these technologies for third-party related advertising or for storing/collecting personal information. For more information please see our Privacy Policy.

You accept our Terms and Privacy Policy when using our website

Before accessing the Website you should carefully read the terms set out in our Terms of Website Use and our Privacy Policy as these will apply to the entire contents of the Website and to any correspondence between us and you.